trikepilot said:
But the little bike performance that we are aiming for almost universally is accomplished on tubed tires - namely your past KTM and WR and current DR. I do not often hear you using terms like "dealbreaker" when you discuss taking your DR out to thrash around the WV woods. It has a tube and does just fine.
Changing out a tubed tire on a KTM single, WR, or DR is just an entirely different proposition than doing the same on a big bike like the AT. Yes, the AT is somewhat lighter than the S10, but it is a lot closer to the S10 in size/weight than to any KTM single or the WR. And bikes like the WR simply don't rack up the huge pavement miles that liter-bikes do. When I owned a KTM 300 and a DRZ, I was fine dumping them on their side or slinging them over the nearest log to fix a flat, but doing this sort of thing on the shoulder of the interstate in 95-deg heat or rain is an entirely different ball game.
I really like what I'm seeing with this new Honda, but despite snazzy videos with super-skilled dirt riders doing lots of wheelies, jumps, and river crossings (in which all the crashes have been edited out), this is still a very big bike that is primarily going to be used for mixed pavement-dirt adventure touring (with 90% of the dirt being gravel and forest service roads). It's still not a dirt bike and anyone buying it to ride hard-core dirt is very brave, very rich, and very foolish. Heck, its weight is really only a handful less than the R1200GS and about the same as the new V-Strom! (It does appear to have a little more suspension which is good.)
Anybody who think flats are some super-rare occurrence has either been lucky or doesn't ride very much. In my 46-yr riding career I've had about 10 and all the folks I ride with have similar statistics. This is about a 30% chance of a flat every year, hardly insignificant. And tubes are much less safe than tubeless, both from a heat-build-up standpoint and because a tubed tire is much more likely to de-bead after a failure. For a 70-mph top-speed dirtbike, no big deal, but the AT is capable of big speed over long distances.
When Honda puts factory tubeless on the AT, I'll be a player. But I'm just not going down the rat hole again of changing tubes on the road. And aftermarket tubeless solutions all have major, major compromises and problems.
- Mark