~
Since I have been following this issue since the beginning I thought I might chime in here and offer up a few thoughts and observations...
One, I honestly don't think there is any one single, solitary cause to this problem. IMHO, it is a combination of things that leads to the failure. As has been noted here so often, resistance is what's driving the problem, but I don't think it's any one particular spot of resistance that one can pinpoint. Instead, it is a culmination of the plug pins from the harness to the sub-harness being marginally sized for their purpose, the wire being borderline for it's use (either due to materials, construction, size, or combination of these factors), and the plug to the bulb itself being perhaps just adequate for the job. If all these components just meet their design specification, or even slightly exceed it, then there is no problem and the headlamps function OK without any discernible problem...
However, if any one of these components or their construction, materials, etc. fall just on the low side of the factory design spec then suddenly you have excessive resistance, excessive heat, and either a cooked, crumbling headlamp plug or a melted, burned, toasted wire... And failure. Certainly there are ways to address any single one of these potential areas the harness can fall below spec - the plugs or the wire, etc. - and *PERHAPS* this will luckily enough keep your harness from failing. However, if you address one and it is, indeed, another part of the *chain* of the harness then you are still going experience failure at some point. Just note the folks who have tried different spade plugs, or dielectric grease, or modifying the existing bulb plugs, etc. and then have still had a failure on down the road. That point alone should lead one to the logical conclusion that there is more than one factor involved here.
Mind you, I obtained all the parts and materials to construct what I believe would be a truly foolproof, dead-bang reliable headlamp sub-harness, then never built it. Instead, I installed the factory replacement harness Yamaha gave me and have been running it for thousands and thousands of miles since - trouble-free. From all appearances that replacement harness was identical to the original harness in mine that cooked off. And it was that original harness which precipitated me to start this thread. One day I still plan to build the *improved* harness, but until then I just watch the one I have and continue to ride, ride, ride.
There is no doubt in my mind that Yamaha spec'ed a headlamp sub-harness that would adequately serve the bike with standard 55-watt bulbs, but that doesn't necessarily mean that their supplier who made the harnesses manufactured each one to actually meet or exceed that specification. This is where I *THINK* the problem lies, and it's why one harness works fine while others fail. Perhaps now Yamaha has a good enough handle on quality control and inspection of the harnesses that any replacement harnesses will not have any issues. That said, if you have one that has *NOT* failed and you want to insure that yours doesn't then the logical conclusion is that you have to address *ALL* the potential areas that might cause the increased resistance, its subsequent heat, and the inevitable failure should one component in your harness be suspect.
Just because the ultimate failure point is at the headlamp plug or wire immediately leading up to it does *NOT* mean that's necessarily the only spot of increased resistance. There could be enough resistance elsewhere in the harness that initially leads to increased heat, which in turn leads to further increased resistance and heat, which then leads to expansion of the headlamp spade plug ends, which further increases resistance and ultimately - failure. In other words, it could be a *runaway* effect started by component inadequacies elsewhere from the plug itself. It's just that's where it finally fails because that's where the problems leading up to the failure manifest themselves in the greatest deviation from spec.
By all means, it doesn't hurt to do any or all of the various tips and tricks in this thread... bending the spade tabs on the headlamp plug to increase tension (and therefore contact force), filing the ends of the headlamp plug to allow it to set deeper on the bulb tabs, dielectric grease to lessen corrosion and act somewhat as a heat sink compound, etc., etc., etc.... But until the entire harness is addressed as a *complete system* and modified accordingly then you will never be 100% sure the problem will not occur.
Just my two centavos... YMMV.
Dallara
~