A survey: Issue count to send to yamaha

autoteach

New Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
871
Location
Belgium WI
It seems rather interesting that the ones that won't accept "hard starting" as anything other than a manufacturer defect are also the ones that can't explain fuel injection logic, refuse to listen to others on the matter, and know more than those who have spent the time to explain how the computer determines the metering of fuel. Once again, my Subaru does this often, my Chevy Blazer did it more times than I could count, and my super tenere has done it once. Solution, always, is the same... well, that is unless you refuse to follow the WOT cranking method. Then you can pull plugs, and crank the motor over without the FI fuse and rub a shamrock between your cheeks. I guess I am allergic to shamrocks.
 

jaeger22

Member
2012 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Jul 1, 2012
Messages
358
Location
Orlando, FL
First I must apologize to Graham, it was indeed his fine work I was referring to.
Dallara, Funny story about the BSA Goldstar and it brings back memories. One of my riding buddies back in the day had a 441 Victor. He loved it and could ride the heck out of it but was I too chicken to start it. ??? LOL
Yes I am 100% sure I did the same process as always. BUT I do not wait for the little dashboard display to stop. You may be on to something there. More on that below.
Yes AC is probably the most knowledgeable person around on the S10 maps. But I have the same Fast Tune tool and access to the same maps. One of my minor disappointments with it was that we do not have access to ALL the maps. All the main ones for sure but not the cranking pulse map or warm up enrichment for instance. On my DIY system cranking pulse is a separate map addressed by coolant temperature. It is very rich and if I remember right, ranges from around .7 to 3 times the "Required Fuel" value depending on how cold it is. "Required Fuel" is essentially the injector open time required for WFO. All the other values in the in the normal fuel tables are refereed to as volumetric efficiency and are a percent of RF. So VE * RF and several other minor tweak factors yield injector open time. (simplified) Anyway I digress, and it was pointed out that I can't explain fuel injection logic. . . ::)
Jaeger, you like to mention how similar so many EFI systems are, and I agree with you. But then you change tacks and say the Super Tenere must be fundamentally different to have this "hard start" issue.
No never said that, it is very similar to the others. But I believe there is minor a bug somewhere. We often say in my world, a debugged piece or software is one who's explode inputs have not been tried yet. ;)
Now to the important part.
First I did RTFM ;D and I do not fine anywhere any direction to wait for the display to finish before starting. I would think if that were important, Yamaha would have given us a clue. Aso if they thought it was a risk, they could just block it from starting until it was finished in the ECU. Trivial software.
Second, I did actually experimenter with deliberately hitting the start button at various points during the display initialization cycle and could never detect any difference. And I did not expect to. See next.
Third, do not confuse what you see on the display with the initialization of the EFI! The EFI loop runs somewhere in the 500 to 1000 times a second range. So it does all it's needed initialization in a millisecond or so. Then it is ready to go. The little display dance we see is very very slow so that we poor very slow humans can see it. Also because it is driving analog needles and they can only go so fast.
So starting before the display finishes is not IMHO operator error.
That all being said, here is where I think you may be on to something! What if there is a bug in the way the ECU handles the interrupt subroutines for the display dance such that if you hit the starter at EXACTLY the right time it gets lost? This kind of issue is not at all unknown in my EE world. That would pretty much explain everything we are seeing. It is of course just a wild theory and I don't know how we would ever prove it but it sure make a good argument for following your recommendation to wait for the display to finish before starting. ::008::
I still say that would be a fault and not an operator error but there may be an operator workaround. Can't hurt.
 

Dallara

Creaks When Walks
Founding Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2010
Messages
2,195
Location
South Texas
~


Damn, Jaeger...

Now I can't figure out if we really do agree or still disagree! ::025::

No worries, though. It's all fun! To me the real point is that the "hard start" issue is really only as big a deal as one chooses to make it. Hell, maybe just worrying that it will happen is what sets it off! I don't worry about it, so it never happens to me. ::025::

Seriously, I fully understand everything you've said, and have to fundamentally agree with it all, but by the same token I'm still convinced that the majority of the time it's operator induced, whether it's the precise timing of interrupting a subroutine or simply inadvertently doing something else. I was always taught to let all those little "self tests" complete before trying to start any vehicle, just like you wait for a computer to completely boot up before trying to do anything with one. Maybe that's why I've never had a "hard start", maybe not. In the end, I doubt we're going to find the cure here, though I think it's great so many are trying to figure it out.

Best part is that this "hard start" issue, much as you said earlier, is more of an annoyance than something anyone should worry about. If one ever feels they are having a "hard start" the bail-out procedure is well known and apparently effective the vast majority of the time. If one keeps a good battery in their machine, keeps it charged, and pays attention it's apparently doubtful anyone will get stranded.

Most amazing tidbit to me about this whole "hard start" conundrum is that it has rarely, if ever, happened to anyone away from home. Seems like it is an "in your own garage" or driveway affliction. Now that's something to really make ya' wonder! ::025::

Enjoyed having the discussion with ya'! ::003::

Dallara



~
 

Dallara

Creaks When Walks
Founding Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2010
Messages
2,195
Location
South Texas
RED CAT said:
Hey. Time for a break guys. Lets skip to something else beside the Hard Start issue.

Yessir, Mr. Red Cat sir! Right away, sir! ::025::

After all, there are sooooooooooooooooooooooo many other issues with the Super Tenere to chat about... ::017::

OK, folks. My apologies. Back to your regularly scheduled snoozefest that was this thread, and that "list" of all those multitude of problems upon problems that no one will ever actually send to Yamaha... and even if they did not more than one or two people at Yamaha will ever read it before summarily deleting it from their email inbox!

Back to the massive flurry of activity of this thread before Jaeger and I screwed it all up with a discussion of the "hard start" issue! :D

Dallara



~
 

arjayes

Active Member
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Dec 13, 2013
Messages
460
Location
San Diego
I've personally enjoyed the hell out of the back and forth on the hard start issue. I think a gentlemanly wager is called for between Dallara and whoever feels strongly enough on the other side of the debate to risk some cash on it. ;D
 

Rasher

Active Member
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 25, 2011
Messages
1,955
Location
UK
I reckon this headlight harness issue is operator error ::002::
 

SuperJimbo

Ride there....
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Jul 19, 2013
Messages
189
Location
NE TX.
Rasher said:
I reckon this headlight harness issue is operator error ::002::
Well at least Ive got a recall notice from the big Y telling me to report to the nearest dealership sickbay for the free fix!
Now to ::002:: on the hard start- not every single part of the FI is read by the ECU and therefore the speculation will persist until
there is that proverbial 'ah-so!' moment of truth. If every single variable in the mix was multiplexed, you'd see a lot more expensive machine.
Got to hand it to the Ducati bunch, I like their one touch system of startup. Eliminates the potential for rider error, as such.
Not that we need it on the S10, Im good with it like it is.
 

snakebitten

Well-Known Member
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
5,681
Location
Coastal Texas
Actually, since the 14 has a different clutch basket, it did get on their radar. Or it seems so.
 

greg the pole

There are no stupid questions, only stupid people
Joined
Apr 18, 2012
Messages
3,343
Location
Calgary AB
snakebitten said:
Actually, since the 14 has a different clutch basket, it did get on their radar. Or it seems so.
isn't Tabasco working on a upgraded basket?
I have not noticed the shudder at the mentioned rpm...too busy revving the daylights out of the motor!
wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!
 
Top