I have switched saddle bag colors from silver to black going from my 2012 to my 2013. I have a silver OEM top case left over from my 2012. I was thinking of painting the silver panels to match the new black saddle bags but a better sollution may be to sell the silver and buy a new black top case so they match perfectly. I do not recall any blemishes on the top case and believe it is in perfect condition. I will have a look at it in the morning when I get off work, take a couple of pictures, and come up with a price if your interested.