Not wishing to bang BMW's drum, but considering that they outsell S10's at least 30:1 (I'm sure someone knows the exact figure), there were not that many failures, agree the older 1100/1150 GS' were more industrial, but even so, look at how K-series they sell compared to failures...... Let's not bash a brand that does most of it pretty well, even when they fail, people still buy them, that's 'branding'.